The Wish Book Was the Original Infinite Scroll
Photo: Bryan, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Before the internet, the Wish Book arrived like a paper internet. It was heavy, glossy, and full of things you did not know you wanted. Sears had one. JCPenney had one. Montgomery Ward had one. For generations of American families, the department store catalog was the place to browse tools, toys, appliances, clothes, and furniture without leaving the kitchen table. Then the web showed up, the catalogs thinned out, and the big books started disappearing from mailboxes. A small group of archivists is now scanning them page by page before the paper gives out.
The Amazon Before the Internet
People joke that the catalog was the original infinite scroll. It was not infinite, but it felt that way. A good Wish Book could run hundreds of pages. It had a toy section that children treated like a sacred text. It had appliances, farm equipment, work boots, holiday decorations, and items that made you wonder who exactly was ordering a combination footstool and radio. The catalog was commerce, but it was also a catalog of American desire.
The volunteers behind the rescue efforts are not all professional librarians. Some are collectors. Some are genealogists. Some are people who remember circling items in the margins and want that experience to remain searchable. They source copies from estate sales, library discards, flea markets, and the occasional box in a relative’s attic. Then they scan, crop, color-correct, and describe. It is slow work. A single volume can take hours, and a complete run can take years.
The Scanner Is the Easy Part
The scanning is tedious but straightforward. The hard part is everything around it. Old catalogs are brittle. Pages tear. Staples rust. Mold happens. Some volumes are missing covers or order forms. Others have been cut up by people who framed their favorite pages. The archivists have to decide what to prioritize, how to handle damaged copies, and what metadata matters. Is the price important? The page number? The item number? The illustration style? The address of the store? The answer is usually yes.
There is also the question of copyright and access. Most of these catalogs are long out of print, and the archives are usually free to browse. The goal is not to compete with the retailers. The goal is to keep a record of what was sold, how it was presented, and what it cost. That record is useful to historians, designers, collectors, and anyone trying to remember the exact lamp that sat in their grandmother’s living room.
What the Circled Items Tell Us
A catalog is not a neutral document. It is a sales pitch, but it is also a scrapbook of human attention. The most interesting copies are the ones with handwriting. A child circles a bicycle. A parent marks a winter coat. Someone writes a budget on the order form. Someone else writes 'too much' next to a washing machine. These marks turn a mass-produced book into a personal artifact.
The archivists often scan those marks too. They do not clean them up. They do not crop them out. The circles and arrows and margin notes are part of the story. They show what people wanted, what they could afford, and what they settled for. In that sense, the Wish Book was never just a catalog. It was a negotiation between fantasy and budget, printed on cheap paper and delivered to the door.
A Catalog Is a Time Machine With a Spine
The work is not glamorous. It involves dust, flatbed scanners, spreadsheets, and a lot of squinting at tiny type. But it matters. These catalogs show how Americans shopped, decorated, dressed, cooked, and dreamed. They show the rise of credit, the spread of suburbs, the changing shape of toys, and the quiet disappearance of entire product categories. They also show how much of everyday life was designed to be thrown away.
As of 2026, the volunteers are still scanning. Some projects are public. Some are private collections waiting for a home. The goal is not to save every single page. The goal is to save enough that the next person who asks 'what did a Sears catalog look like in 1978?' does not have to rely on a blurry memory. It is a very SpotDW kind of archive: unglamorous, specific, and built one page at a time. The Wish Book may be gone from the mailbox, but it is not gone yet.